Commit graph

2 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
ScreenTinker 6ac272af57 Pi installer: stop advertising what was never installed (#245)
Three reports from the same operator, two of them the script describing a
state it never reached — the same shape as the first round of #245.

Guide missing sudo: frontend/guides/raspberry-pi-digital-signage.html said
`curl -sL … | bash` while the script's own header and its root check both say
`| sudo bash`. The script fails loudly with the right command, so nothing is
half-installed, but the guide should not have to be corrected by an error
message. Also documents the --player-only form, which the guide never showed.

MOTD advertised commands that mode did not create: section 11 creates
screentinker-status/update/logs only when PLAYER_ONLY is false, while section
12 wrote an /etc/motd listing all three unconditionally. A Player-Only Pi
therefore greeted its operator with three commands that were not on it, at
every SSH login. The command list is now appended per-mode.

The cheap fix would have been to print nothing on a player. That trades a
wrong banner for a machine nobody can inspect over SSH, so Player-Only now
gets its own screentinker-status (kiosk state, which server it points at, and
whether that server is actually reachable) and screentinker-logs (kiosk).
screentinker-update is genuinely not applicable — there is no local server to
update — and is not offered.

Wayland cursor never hidden: the launcher stated the compositor cursor config
was written "below when wayfire.ini exists". It never was — wayfire.ini and
hide_cursor each appeared exactly once in the whole script, both inside that
comment. unclutter is installed but only runs on the X11 branch, so a Wayland
Pi kept a mouse pointer on the sign while the install looked complete. Now
configures wayfire's hide-cursor plugin at install time, idempotently and
after backing the file up, and says plainly that labwc has no equivalent
rather than failing silently.

Tests: raspberry-pi-setup.test.js gains a check that no MOTD advertises a
command its mode does not install (both modes, extracted from the script
rather than re-typed), that a player is not left with zero diagnostics, and
that the Wayland cursor claim is backed by code outside a comment. Both
mutations verified to fail: putting screentinker-update back in the player
MOTD, and removing the hide-cursor write.

NOT fixed, and not guessed at: the ALT+F4-on-first-pairing symptom and the
reconnect storm. The crash-restore fix those would need is already in 1.9.33
and targets a different symptom, and `observed=6/5 per 10000ms` is six
reconnects in ten seconds, which matches neither the solo-widget cycle nor the
kiosk RestartSec=10. Both need the kiosk-side log — which, until this commit,
a Player-Only Pi had no command to read.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Bvjey4FNam49MN7ybjcq6A
2026-08-10 10:50:34 -05:00
ScreenTinker 0efbc6040e Pi installer: ask the operator, not the pipe; and stop assuming X11
Five defects from #245, all found by a user on a Pi 5 because nothing in this
repo has ever executed either of these scripts.

THE MENU IGNORED THE OPERATOR.

The documented install is `curl … | sudo bash`, which makes stdin the SCRIPT.
bash has consumed it by the time any `read` runs, so every prompt got EOF
instantly: the mode menu "chose" All-in-One without anyone touching it, and
Player-Only could not be reached that way at all. Reported as the menu being
skipped, because it was. Prompts now read the controlling terminal, and when
there genuinely is no terminal the script SAYS which way it went instead of
letting an empty answer look like a decision.

X11 TOOLS ON A WAYLAND PI.

Pi 5 on Bookworm defaults to Wayland, where xset, unclutter and xrandr are
no-ops that log an error and do nothing. The Pi therefore got no blanking
suppression and no cursor hiding while looking configured. The launcher now
detects the session and branches: X11 keeps what it had, Wayland gets wlopm and
--ozone-platform=wayland, and the compositor-side alternatives are documented
rather than silently assumed.

THE KEYRING PROMPT.

"Choose password for keyring" on every boot is Chromium reaching for
gnome-keyring. A kiosk has nobody to answer it. --password-store=basic.

THE WHITE PAGE ON EVERY BOOT BUT THE FIRST.

Chromium restoring a session it believes crashed — a kiosk is killed by
shutdown and never exits cleanly, so it returns with a restore surface over the
player. That is why ALT+F4 "fixed" it: it closed the surface, not the player.
Rewriting exited_cleanly was never enough on its own because the previous window
set is replayed from Sessions/, so that goes too.

THE BANNER SPELLED THE PRODUCT WRONG.

The ASCII art read "Scree Tinker" — the n was missing, and it is the first thing
anyone sees over SSH.

Also answered the reporter's Overlay FS question in the README, including the
part that bites: an All-in-One Pi IS the server, so an overlay discards the
database, uploads and JWT secret at every reboot. Safe for Player-Only; needs
DATA_DIR moved off the overlay otherwise.

The new test generates the kiosk launcher exactly as the installer writes it and
runs bash -n over it, because `bash -n` on the outer script cannot see inside a
heredoc — a syntax error in there is just text until it reaches a screen.

Reported-by: carloblu74
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_014skWYXJUWhF73EvNPgB2AS
2026-08-07 09:08:17 -05:00